3.6.6. Lands with Wilderness Characteristics

The BLM is required to inventory lands to determine whether they possess wilderness characteristics. The BLM Land Use Planning Handbook (H-1601-1) states that the BLM must consider the management of lands with wilderness characteristics (LWCs) during the land use planning process. The criteria used to identify these lands are essentially the same criteria as identified in the recently-released BLM Manual 6301.

In addition to the inventory requirements in H-1601-1, on December 22, 2010 the Secretary of the Interior released Secretarial Order 3310, Protecting Wilderness Characteristics on Lands Managed by the Bureau of Land Management. This Secretarial Order emphasizes the need to protect wilderness characteristics where they occur on BLM-administered land, and directs the BLM to regularly maintain its wilderness resource inventories. Secretarial Order 3310 further directs the BLM to protect LWCs through the land use planning and other decision processes unless the impairment of those characteristics is determined to be appropriate and consistent with other laws and resource management considerations. To address this Secretarial Order, the BLM has released manuals 6301, 6302, and 6303; these manuals implement the Secretarial Order and were therefore used to focus the BLM’s inventory and analysis of LWCs in this document.

The inventory process utilized by the Cody and Worland Field Offices is consistent with the process for conducting inventories for LWCs on BLM lands outlined in Manual 6301. Section 201 of FLPMA requires the BLM to maintain an inventory of all public lands and their resources. The process outlined in Manual 6301 includes the following review steps:

1. an analysis of roads and other impacts to naturalness;

2. an analysis of wilderness characteristics; and

3. a boundary delineation process to define the area with wilderness characteristics and to exclude substantially noticeable human-caused impacts.

Inventoried areas that meet the size, naturalness, and the outstanding solitude and/or the outstanding primitive and unconfined recreation criteria are described as LWCs. A detailed discussion of the process the BLM used in the inventory appears below.

The BLM performed an inventory of lands in the Planning Area to determine if any BLM-administered lands had wilderness characteristics. Wilderness characteristics are resource values that include naturalness, outstanding opportunities for solitude, and outstanding opportunities for primitive and unconfined recreation. Areas evaluated for wilderness characteristics generally occur in undeveloped locations of sufficient size (usually at least 5,000 acres) to be practical to manage for these characteristics. Smaller areas are considered if they are contiguous with designated Wilderness or WSAs, or are of a manageable size.

As the basis for this inventory, the BLM reviewed comments made during public scoping and recommendations developed during an internal review of multiple-use lands in the Planning Area. In addition, the lands considered included areas recommended as part of the “Wilderness at Risk: Citizens’ Wilderness Proposal for Wyoming BLM-administered Lands” submitted to the BLM by the Wyoming Wilderness Association in February 2004 (Wyoming Wilderness Coalition 2004). The Citizens’ Wilderness Proposal promoted the designation of approximately 1.1 million acres of BLM-administered lands for wilderness statewide, of which approximately 283,709 acres are in the Planning Area. In addition to the Citizens’ Wilderness Proposal, the BLM considered a Biodiversity Conservation Alliance proposal for a formal wilderness inventory of lands in the McCullough Peaks area.

The BLM analyzed the Planning Area to determine which, if any, lands met the wilderness characteristics criteria. As part of the analysis, the BLM evaluated whether the areas were of a sufficient size; were in a natural condition; and possessed outstanding opportunities for solitude or presented opportunities for primitive and unconfined recreation (see an example inventory form in Appendix S). The inventory identified 51 LWCs in the Planning Area (Map 63). Table 3–46 lists the acreage and other resource values for each area. The final evaluation forms are available for public review at the WFO and the CYFO and on their respective websites.

At present, the BLM manages LWCs in accordance with the current RMPs. No specific management for retention of wilderness characteristics exists under the current RMPs. Current management for LWCs appears in Table 3–47.

Table 3.46. Lands with Wilderness Characteristics and Other Resource Values and Uses

Lands with Wilderness Characteristics Area Name

Acres

Supplemental Resource Values

Valid Existing Rights Present

Locatable Mineral Development Potential

Moderate Oil and Gas Development Potential

Scientifically-significant Fossil Potential

In holdings and/or Access Issues

Existing ROW or ROW Corridor

Limited Manageability (insufficient size, configuration)

Proximity to Wildland Urban Interface

0008 DH

6,417

Cultural Resources; Paleontological Resources; Special Status Species

Yes

Yes

0016 DH

6,186

Paleontological Resources

Yes

Yes

0048 PR

8,771

None identified

Yes

Yes

005 PR

8,014

Cultural Resources; Special Status Species

Yes

Yes

Yes

069 JW

1,056

Wildlife Resources; Scenic

Yes

Yes

Yes

130 JW

248

Wildlife Resources; Scenic; Cultural Resources

Yes

Yes

1535 PR

17,458

Cultural Resources

Yes

1536 PR

10,685

Cultural Resources

Yes

31 PR

2,972

Cultural Resources

Yes

Yes

508 AK

4,035

Scenic; Cultural Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

508 TriState Gooseberry N Platte

13,464

Wildlife Resources; Cultural Resources; Paleontological Resources; Topographic Features

Yes

Yes

509 AK

13,873

Wild Horses; Wildlife Resources; Cultural Resources; Paleontological Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

509 AK Dorsey Ck.

4,578

Cultural Resources; Paleontological Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

516 DH

553

Wildlife Resources; Special Status Species; Recreation; Scenic

Yes

Yes

568 TS

2,491

Wildlife Resources; Special Status Species; Recreation; Scenic

Yes

Yes

577 AK

7,107

Wildlife Resources; Paleontological Resources; Cultural Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

622 AK

29,690

Wildlife Resources; Scenic; Cultural Resources; Special Status Species

Yes

Yes

Yes

626 AK

10,280

Scenic; Cultural Resources

Yes

Yes

639 AK

13,921

Cultural Resources; Paleontological Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

651 AK

6,410

Cultural Resources; Paleontological Resources; Topographic Features; Wildlife Resources

Yes

Yes

652 Lower, Upper AK

21,153

Paleontological Resources; Wild Horses; Wildlife Resources

Yes

Yes

661 TS

743

Wildlife Resources; Scenic; Cultural Resources

Yes

Yes

665 CW

15,688

Recreation; Scenic; Topographic Features

Yes

Yes

Yes

668 AK

3,435

Cultural Resources; Paleontological Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

669 AK

8,387

Cultural Resources; Paleontological Resources; Wild Horses; Wildlife Resources

Yes

Yes

676 AK, PR

14,225

Cultural Resources; Paleontological Resources; Wild Horses; Wildlife Resources

Yes

Yes

Alkali Creek NW CP

4,444

Cultural Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Bald Ridge

7,077

Special Status Species; Wildlife Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Bobcat Draw South CP

4,200

Scenic; Cultural Resources; Paleontological Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Bobcat Draw South II CP

7,567

Scenic; Cultural Resources

Yes

Bobcat Draw West CP

5,511

Scenic; Cultural Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Carter Mountain

14,496

Special Status Species; Vegetation Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Cedar Ridge

6,364

None identified

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Coon Creek

30,769

None identified

Yes

Yes

Crystal Creek

15,165

Scenic; Public Access

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Honeycombs 164 CP

1,157

Paleontological Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Honeycombs NW 107 CP

2,026

Cultural Resources; Paleontological Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Honeycombs South CP

34,487

Cultural Resources; Paleontological Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Little Dry Creek

48,929

Scenic

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Medicine Lodge North CP

6,322

Scenic; Cultural Resources

Yes

N. YU Bench

25,097

Open Space

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Owl Creek CP

7,423

Scenic; Cultural Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Painted Hills

9,182

None identified

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Paintrock CP

8,809

Scenic; Cultural Resources

Yes

Rattlesnake Mountain

18,663

Special Status Species

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Red Butte North CP

11,777

Cultural Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Rough Gulch

12,508

Wild Horses

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Sheep Mountain South CP

2,172

Paleontological Resources

Yes

Sheep Mountain

13,063

Special Status Species; Wildlife Resources

Yes

Yes

Yes

Trout Creek

4,514

Fish and Wildlife Resources; Special Status Species

Yes

Whistle Creek

37,727

Wild Horses

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes


Source: BLM 2009s, BLM 2009a
CP Citizens Proposed
ROW Rights-of-way

Table 3.47. Acreage of Current Management in Lands with Wilderness Characteristics

Minerals Management

Rights-of-Way

Visual Resources Management

Travel Management

Withdrawn from Locatable Mineral Entry

Mineral Materials Closure

Administratively Unavailable for Mineral Leasing

Exclusion

Avoidance/Mitigation

Open

Class I

Class II

Class III

IV

Closed

Limited to Designated Roads and Trails

Limited to Existing Roads and Trails

Open

Seasonal Restrictions

23,139

17,108

6,099

14,901

150,888

405,499

< 1

137,496

137,709

295,962

3,095

176,691

386,703

0

4,798


Source: BLM 2009a
< less than

Secretarial Order 3310 and Manual 6302 establish the BLM’s approach for considering LWCs in land use planning documents (e.g., RMP revisions), and provide guidance on when to manage LWCs as administratively designated Wild Lands. The guidance states that “the BLM shall protect LWCs when undertaking land use planning by avoiding impairment of their wilderness characteristics unless the BLM concludes, as part of its decision-making process, that impairing wilderness characteristics is appropriate and consistent with applicable requirements of law and other resource management considerations… Where the BLM concludes, through land use planning, that protection of wilderness characteristics is appropriate, the BLM shall designate these lands as Wild Lands.” The decision making process the BLM uses to evaluate LWCs during the preparation of land use plans are the management alternatives (see Chapter 2 of this document for potential management actions for LWCs in the Planning Area). Under Manual 6302, in determining whether impairment is appropriate BLM should consider factors such as the quality of the LWC resources and non-LWC resources and/or uses, the impact of allowing various uses on the LWC parcel, and valid existing rights. Valid existing rights may be present within the LWCs.

In making Wild Land designations, BLM will consider, as outlined in Manual 6302, manageability and resource values and uses including, but not limited to, the following:

Table 3-46 provides information on other resource uses and values within each LWC.